Question: Would a Shenmue 3, made on the budget of a Yakuza game, be a major seller?
Seriously, I mean we've had this conversation many times before in other threads, but I'm curious if fans would accept a Shenmue 3 if it meant a lower budget than the first two, a little more of the same in terms of in-game gimmicks (magic weather, collectables, arcade games, menial jobs) and a greater emphasis on story? Personally, I want STORY resolution. New gimmicks would be great, but I'd rather SEGA not spend a load of money to reinvent the wheel and try to redefine adventure games.
Would this be so crazy a way to get to Shenmue 3: In 2013 release Shenmue HD, in early 2014 release Shenmue 2 HD, if sales are strong and Shenmue hype has reached strong levels announce Shenmue 3 at E3 or TGS in 2014 (E3 preferably, given the series popularity in the West) and begin a series of videos released to the SEGA YouTube channels discussing the game's development. Make it very apparent that Shenmue 3's focus will be story as well as enhanced fighting mechanics (borrow ideas from VF5). That way people's expectations will be set, and we won't have a Phantom Menace on our hands.
Then, in 2016 release Shenmue 3 to PS4, XBOX 720 and (I guess) Wii U. Or, make it a console exclusive a la Bayonetta 2 to put more money behind it. I'd prefer MS or Sony, but even if Nintendo backed it I'd be okay with that. Just want a third game made one way or another.
---
I guess what triggered me thinking all this was playing Binary Domain over the weekend. It's a fantastic game, but it got me thinking about how it's a new IP that didn't have the strongest of sales (did it?). Yet it got released. So why is it so hard to release a single game like Shenmue 3? Surely a Shenmue 3 made with a budget equal to, or a little greater than, Binary Domain would sell very well. I just think that the Shenmue series has long since passed it's cult status and that a game in today's world would sell very well. Especially if SEGA built up the series again via HD rereleases and then gave us a third title next generation. If we can get multiple Yakuza titles and new IPs like Binary Domain, why not a Shenmue 3 with a smaller budget but a bigger focus on story? Team Yu Suzuki with the minds behind the Yakuza games and give us a really strong finish to the series that pulls at our heartstrings and nostalgia. Leave reinventing action/adventure games to games like Watch Dogs.