SEGAbits Forums
Gaming => General Gaming Discussion => Topic started by: Sharky on February 07, 2010, 03:07:42 pm
-
Good Sega games & reviews/scores for games released in 2010!
(If anyone wants to help me out with some of the review scores I've missed go ahead!)
-Bayonetta (360/PS3)
Famitsu: 40/40
EDGE: 10/10
Gamesradar: 10/10
Eurogamer.es : 10/10
Hyper mag: 10/10
IGN UK: 9.6/10 (X360)
IGN: 9.5/10 (X360)
-Phantasy Star Zero (DS)
RPGFan: 80 out of 100
Worth Playing: 8.5 out of 10
Nintendo Power: 8 out of 10
Cheat Code Central: 4.7 out of 5
1UP: B-
-Resonance of Fate/End of Eternity (360/PS3)
Famitsu: 8,9,8,9 (34/40)
EuroGamer: 8/10
-Sonic & Sega All-Star Racing (360/PS3/PC/Wii/DS)
Game Observer: 8.5/10
Games Master: 8.3/10
Nintendo Power: 8/10
GameSpot: 8/10
IGN: 8/10
1up: B
GamesRadar: 8/10
VideoGamer: 8/10
GameInformer: 7.5/10
-Valkyria Chronicles 2 (PSP)
Famitsu: 9/9/9/8 (35/40)
IGN: 9.0
Destructoid: 9.5/10
Joystiq: 4/5
Game Informer: 8.5/10
Game Trailers: 8.4/10
-Yakuza 3 (PS3)
Famitsu: 38/40
Eurogamer 8/10.
CVG: 9/10
IGN: 8.5/10
X-Play: 4/5
Hyper Mag: 8/10
-Alien vs Predator (360/PS3/PC)
IGN UK: 8.5/10 (Editors Choice Award)
OXM UK: 8/10
TechDigital: 4/5
-Napoleon Total War (PC)
IGN:8.9/10
EuroGamer: 8/10
Hyper Mag: 9/10.
-Yakuza 4 (PS3) JP
Famitsu: 9,10,10,9 (38/40)
-7th Dragon 'platinum release' (DS) JP
Famitsu: 9/8/8/8 (33)
-Infinate Space (DS)
Eurogamer: 7/10
Sakura Wars 5 (Not Sega published in west)
IGN: 9.0/10
Nintendo Magazine UK: 8.1/10
Nintendo Power: 7.5/10
RPGamer: 7/10
Edge: 7/10
-After Burner Climax (PSN/XBLA)
EuroGamer: 7/10
-Sonic the Hedgehog 4 (PSN/XBLA/WiiWare/iPhone)
GamesRadar: 9/10
SPOnG: 86%
PSM3 magazine: 8.2/10
IGN: 8/10
IGN UK: 8/10
RunDLC: 4/5
Game Informer: 8/10
Eurogamer: 9/10
XGN.nl: 8.5/10
1up: B
totalvideogames.com: 9/10
gamers daily news: 8/10
Game Reactor 8/10 (editor in chief review)
RipTen: 8/10
gaming union: 7
gamercc.com: 87%
Blast Magazine: B
Escapist magazine: 4/5
Original-Gamer.com: 8.5
Game Over Online: 8.2
ONM: 88% (WiiWare)
NintendoLife: 8/10 (WiiWare)
Nintendo Power: Recommended (WiiWare)
SEGABits: B (iPhone)
AppSpy: 4/5 (iPhone)
-VANQUISH (PS3/Xbox360)
Famitsu: 9/9/9/8
Eurogamer: 9/10
Play UK: 93/10
Dengeki PS: 85/85/90/85
Games Radar: 9/10
GameSpot: 9/10
IGN: 8.5/10
-Sonic Colours (Wii)
Eurogamer: 8/10
EuroGamer Italy: 9/10
JoyStiq: 4/5
IGN: 8.5/10
Famitsu: 8/8/8/10
NGamer: 86%
Nintendo Power: 9/10
Official Nintendo Mag: 86%
Telegraph: 8/10
VideoGamer: 8/10
-Sonic Colours (DS)
IGN: 8.5/10
Famitsu: 8/8/8/8
Official Nintendo Mag: 85%
Nintendo Power: 7.5/10
-Sonic Free Riders (Kenect)
IGN.com (US): 7.5
OXM: 7.5
-Sonic Adventure (XBLA/PSN)
Gamezone.com: 7/10 (PSN)
playstationlifestyle.net: 8/10 (PSN)
gamersdailynews.com: 7.5/10 (XBLA)
-Chu Chu Rocket
IGN: 8.5/10 (iPad)
IGN: 8/10 (iPhone)
Game Zone Online: 8/10
-Phantasy Star Portable 2 (PSP) JP
-Football Manager 2011 (PC/PSP)
IGN: 8/10
-more on the way-
-
NOTE:
-JP = japan/import only
-N/A = not announced
-!Rumour! = not officially announced!
GOOD SEGA GAMES 2009 THREAD:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=14 (http://www.segabits.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=14)
-
Phantasy Star Zero
RPGFan 80 out of 100
Worth Playing 8.5 out of 10
Nintendo Power 8 out of 10
Cheat Code Central 4.7 out of 5
1UP B-
-
Good call, cheers.
-
Sega All Stars
8.0 - Nintendo Power
I'm not going to include the DS version... lol
-
I'm not going to include the DS version... lol
I wont tell if you don't.
-
What if Iron Man 2 gets some good reviews? Yeah, I am serious.
-
What if Iron Man 2 gets some good reviews? Yeah, I am serious.
I don't see why that would be so bad if it ended up being awesome as that batman game.
-
What if Iron Man 2 gets some good reviews? Yeah, I am serious.
I don't see why that would be so bad if it ended up being awesome as that batman game.
Yeah... That is not going to happen, but it is possible for it to actually turn out well. I mean, that guy at Comicon told Kori it was going to kick ass, and why would some guy who works for SEGA lie?
-
Bayonetta got 10/10 from Hyper Magazine, thats Australasia's biggest gaming mag! (I think).
Also, they gave Monkey Ball Step and Roll a 5/10, maybe leave that one out.
-
What if Iron Man 2 gets some good reviews? Yeah, I am serious.
The I'll put it in... This thread is for good games, if it turns out to be a good game I'll happily happily include it in the thread. But as of now I don't expect it to be, so it isnt there.
Again if any of these games turns out to be a complete and utter shit, I'll take it down.
-
I guess Bleach: The 3rd Phantom counts a one of those average-at-best titles. It has some 7/10, but then it's all downhill.
-
I'm guessing nobody here has high hopes for Monkey Ball Step And Roll?
-
^^^It is one of mine and Aki's most wanted releases this year!
-
Yeah I am liking what I see of Monkey Ball so far, especially the co-op mode. I am though worried that they have not made an analogue control scheme for the game though, especially with that one Australia magazine complaining about the controls of the game.
But in terms of SEGA games yet to release, Monkey Ball is near the top of my list.
-
I will be reviewing Super Monkey Ball Step & Roll, if it makes you guys feel a tad better.
-
I personally don't have high hopes for it, namely because of the exclusion of the analogue controls. Or at least I think I read that.
-
Guess GameInformer was being a douchebag about AvP. IGN UK gave it a 8.5/10 (http://http://xbox360.ign.com/articles/106/1068446p1.html).
-
Guess GameInformer was being a douchebag about AvP. IGN UK gave it a 8.5/10 (http://http://xbox360.ign.com/articles/106/1068446p1.html).
Of course they were... its game informer.
Fuck them, they did the same to Sega Racing 5/10...
I say we take a holy Sega crusade and fuck them with a sword... aka, boycott their shit, aka... just not buy their magazine... aka, carry on as we were.
-
They also gave Outrun 2 and Yakuza bad scores. Fuck them :cry:
-
Guess GameInformer was being a douchebag about AvP. IGN UK gave it a 8.5/10 (http://http://xbox360.ign.com/articles/106/1068446p1.html).
Of course they were... its game informer.
Fuck them, they did the same to Sega Racing 5/10...
I say we take a holy Sega crusade and fuck them with a sword... aka, boycott their shit, aka... just not buy their magazine... aka, carry on as we were.
They gave SASR a 5/10? Their latest issue didn't have a SASR review, it only had the AvP one.
Are you sure of this?
-
7TH Dragon will not be reviewed again in Japan... :P
T+
-
7TH Dragon will not be reviewed again in Japan... :P
T+
Doesnt matter I'm grasping at straws here
Woop woop woop woop
-
Another good score for AvP.
8 out of 10 from OXM UK (http://http://www.avpgalaxy.net/2010/02/11/oxm-uk-reviews-avp/)
-
Damn! Also EDGE gave 5/10 to SMB Step&Roll. Unfortunately now is a confirmation. :cry:
-
Don't tell me you're surprised. The Wii Mote controls for Banana Blitz were terrible. Why in god's name would the balance board be better?
-
To be honest I was not expecting much from the Monkey Ball game.
Does anyone have the Japanese review scores for games like Yakuza 3, Valkyira Chronicles 2 and others I may have missed.
-
4 out of 5 from TechDigest.tv (http://http://www.techdigest.tv/2010/02/aliens_vs_preda.html)
AvP Related.
-
To be honest I was not expecting much from the Monkey Ball game.
Does anyone have the Japanese review scores for games like Yakuza 3, Valkyira Chronicles 2 and others I may have missed.
Yakuza 3 got a 38/40 I believe.
-
Famitsu
[PSP] Valkyria Chronicles 2 - 9/9/9/8 (35/40)
[Xbox360 & PS3] End of Eternity (Resonance of Fate) - 8,9,8,9 (34/40)
-
Thanks boys!
Updated:
AvP, Yakuza 3, Valkyria 2, RoF.
-
AvP:
IGN: 7/10
IGN UK: 8.5/10
-
Sonic Chronicles
Gameplayer 12/18/08 Review 9 out of 10
G4 - X-Play 11/20/08 Review 4 out of 5
1up - A
2010
OOPS
-
GamesRadar gave SASASR an 8/10.
-
AVP
5.5 - Game Informer
-
SEGA All Stars Racing
IGN: 8.0
1up: B
-
AVP
5.5 - Game Informer
Ok so, first you post sonic chronicles reviews even though the title says 2010,
then you post a bad score even though the title says 'good' Sega reviews.
I know 'making relentlessly dumb posts' isn't in the forum rules thread, but it's kind of an unwritten law.
The light is on, but nobodies home...
@Shadi/SegaMonkey, putting those up now. Thanks.
-
don't know if these up yet, but listing them anyways
sega all stars racing
gamespot: 8.0
game informer 7.75
-
7th Dragon: 9/8/8/8(33) -GOLD-
;p
-
http://spong.com/feature/10110072/Revie ... ars-Racing (http://spong.com/feature/10110072/Review-Sonic-SEGA-All-Stars-Racing)
8.6
Was written by Sonic Stadium webmaster Dreadknux, by the way.
-
AVP
5.5 - Game Informer
Ok so, first you post sonic chronicles reviews even though the title says 2010,
then you post a bad score even though the title says 'good' Sega reviews.
I know 'making relentlessly dumb posts' isn't in the forum rules thread, but it's kind of an unwritten law.
The light is on, but nobodies home...
@Shadi/SegaMonkey, putting those up now. Thanks.
1st one was by accident
2nd was me trolling :P
Sega All Stars
Game Informer 02/26/10 Review 7.5 out of 10
VideoGamer 02/25/10 Review 8 out of 10
IGN 02/23/10 Review 8 out of 10
1UP 02/23/10 Review B
GameSpot 02/23/10 Review 8 out of 10
Official Nintendo Magazine UK 03/01/10 Review 75 out of 100
Nintendo Power 03/01/10 Review 8 out of 10
Edit: Some of these are already on, but some aren't.
-
Updated with all but that shitty Official Nintendo shit.
-
Hyper mag gave AVP a 7/10 I think, and Napoleon Total War a 9/10.
-
Thanks Ill use the N:TW one.
-
7/10 ain't bad either, but yeah probably not good enough for showcasing the best scores.
-
Eurogamer, Yakuza 3, 8/10.
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/yakuz ... ean-review (http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/yakuza-3-european-review)
-
Yakuza 3:
CVG 9/10
http://www.computerandvideogames.com/ar ... ?id=238249 (http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=238249)
IGN 8.5/10
http://ps3.ign.com/articles/107/1075171p1.html (http://ps3.ign.com/articles/107/1075171p1.html)
-
Sega All-stars Racing got an 8.5 on game observer:
http://www.gameobserver.com/review/insi ... acing-453/ (http://www.gameobserver.com/review/inside/all-platforms/sonic-sega-all-stars-racing-453/)
-
SEGA All Stars Racing
Gametrailers: 8.0
-
EDGE review scores
Alice in Wonderland - 7
Aliens vs Predator - 5
Battlefield Bad Company 2 - 8
BlazBlue - 8
Calling - 5
Final Fantasy XIII - 5
God of War 3 - 8
Infinite Space - 8
Just Cause 2 - 7
No More Heros 2 - 7
P.B. Winterbottom - 8
Sakura Wars: So Long, My Love - 7
White Knight Chronicles - 5
Yakuza 3 - 6
Glad to see Yakuza 3 isn't as good as some movie tie-in game or the worst Sakura Wars game.
But still better than Final Fantasy XIII :afroman:
-
EDGE review scores
Alice in Wonderland - 7
Aliens vs Predator - 5
Battlefield Bad Company 2 - 8
BlazBlue - 8
Calling - 5
Final Fantasy XIII - 5
God of War 3 - 8
Infinite Space - 8
Just Cause 2 - 7
No More Heros 2 - 7
P.B. Winterbottom - 8
Sakura Wars: So Long, My Love - 7
White Knight Chronicles - 5
Yakuza 3 - 6
Glad to see Yakuza 3 isn't as good as some movie tie-in game or the worst Sakura Wars game.
But still better than Final Fantasy XIII :afroman:
Are Edge just trolling their readers now?
-
EDGE sucks, they are known to be the harshest reviewers out there.
I think scores under 3/10 are classified for broken games.. yet. A lot of the games get 3/10.
-
EDGE sucks, they are known to be the harshest reviewers out there.
Actually, they're one of the few out there that understand the concept of "average" and "scale from 1 to 10". This industry thinks "7" is average. lol.
-
EDGE sucks, they are known to be the harshest reviewers out there.
Actually, they're one of the few out there that understand the concept of "average" and "scale from 1 to 10". This industry thinks "7" is average. lol.
7 is average cause dats what I gots on my journalism course in high skool to get this here job
-
Resonance of Fate, 8/10 - Eurogamer (http://http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/resonance-of-fate-review)
-
What the fuck is going on with Edge? Are they just messing with people now?
-
Resonance of Fate -> GameTrailers: 8/10
-
Yakuza 3, 4/5 - X-Play
-
BONUS FEATURE: All time Famitsu's Highest Scores for Sega titles.
*MEGADRIVE*
-Super Monaco GP(9/9/8/8)
-Advanced Taisen Ryaku -Deutsch Dengeki Sakusen-(8/8/8/9)
-Sonic The Hedgehog(8/8/9/8)
-Landstalker(8/8/8/9)
-World of Illusion(9/9/9/9)
-Sonic The Hedgehog CD(9/8/7/8)
-Alladin(9/9/9/8)
-Night Trap(9/8/9/7)
-Yumemi Yakata no Monogatari[Mansion of Hidden Souls](8/7/8/9)
-V.R.(8/9/8/8)
*SATURN*
-Virtua Fighter(9/9/9/9)
-Virtua Fighter Remix(8/10/9/8)
-Clockwork Knight(8/8/8/8)
-Shining Wisdom(8/7/8/9)
-World Advanced Taisen Ryaku(9/9/8/7)
-Sega International Victory Goal(8/8/9/7)
-Virtua Cop(8/9/8/7)
-Virtua Fighter 2(9/10/10/10)
-Sega Rally Championship(9/9/9/9)
-Panzer Dragoon Zwei(9/8/10/8)
-Victory Goal'96(8/10/9/8)
-NiGHTS(8/9/9/8)
-Decathlete(8/8/8/8)
-Fighting Vipers(9/10/9/9)
-Sakura Taisen(8/9/8/8)
-Virtua Cop 2(9/8/8/7)
-Virtual-On(8/8/8/8)
-Victory Goal WORLDWIDE EDITION(8/7/9/8)
-Shining The Holy Ark(8/8/8/8)
-FIGHTER MEGAMIX(9/9/8/9)
-ADVANCED WORLD WAR(7/9/9/7)
-Zen Nippon Pro Wretler FEATURING VIRTUA(8/7/9/8)
-J-LEAGUE Pro Soccer Club wo Tsukurou! 2(9/8/8/8)
-Shining Force III Scenario 1(9/7/8/8)
-AZEL -Panzer Dragoon RPG-(8/9/9/9)
-Winter Heat(8/8/8/8)
-Burning Rangers(8/8/8/8)
-Sakura Taisen 2(9/8/9/7)
-Shining Force III Scenario 3(8/8/8/8)
*DREAMCAST*
-Virtua Fighter 3tb(9/9/9/9)
-SONIC ADVENTURE(9/10/9/10)
-Sega Rally 2(9/9/9/9)
-THE HOUSE OF THE DEAD 2(9/8/8/8)
-Giant Gram: All Japan Pro Wrestling 2 (8/8/8/8)
-J-LEAGUE PRO SOCCER CLUB WO TSUKUROU!(9/9/8/8)
-Chu Chu Rocket!(9/9/8/8)
-ZOMBIE REVENGE(7/8/8/9)
-Virtua Striker 2 ver.2000.1(9/7/8/9)
-Virtual-On ORATORIO TANGRAM(10/10/9/10)
-Shenmue(8/9/8/8)
-NFL 2K(9/9/8/8)
-CRAZY TAXI(8/9/8/9)
-ROOMANIA #203(9/8/8/8)
-SegaGT Homologation Special(8/8/8/9)
-NBA 2K(9/8/8/8)
-THE TYPING OF THE DEAD(8/9/9/9)
-Samba de Amigo(8/8/8/8)
-JET SET RADIO(8/8/8/8)
-Dabitsuku! Derby Stallion wo Tsukurou!(8/8/8/8)
-GIANT GRAM 2000(8/7/8/9)
-Motto Pro Yakyuu Team wo Tsukurou!(9/8/8/7)
-Eternal Arcadia(9/9/8/7)
-Power Smash(8/8/8/9)
-Sakatsuku Tokudaigou J-LEAGUE Pro Soccer Club wo Tsukurou!(8/8/7/9)
-PHANTASY STAR ONLINE(9/9/9/10)
-Sakura Taisen 3(9/8/8/9)
-NFL 2K1(9/7/8/8)
-CRAZY TAXI 2(9/9/8/9)
-SONIC ADVENTURE 2(9/8/7/9)
-Outtrigger(9/8/8/8)
-Pro Yakyuu Team wo Tsukurou! & Asobou!(9/8/7/8)
-Shenmue II(8/8/8/8)
-Fushigi no Dungeon Fuurai no Shiren Gaiden(8/9/8/9)
-Space Channel 5 Part 2(9/8/9/9)
-Sakura Taisen 4(10/9/8/9)
No love for Sega Consoles and games released before Mega-Drive and low scores for classics like Ecco, Sonic 2, Phantasy Star... holy shit (-_-#
Let's continue with the scores after DC's dead.
*PS2*
-Rez(9/8/7/8) --> yeah! DC version got a lower score...
-Virtua Fighter 4(9/9/9/10)
-Space Channel 5 Part 2(9/8/9/9)
-Sakatsuku 2002 J-LEAGUE Pro Soccer Club wo Tsukurou!(9/8/8/9)
-NFL 2K2(8/8/8/8)
-Culdcept Second Expansion(9/9/8/9)
-Shinobi(8/8/7/9)
-NFL 2K3(8/8/8/9)
-Pro Yakyuu Team wo Tsukurou! 2(9/8/8/7)
-Sakura Taisen Atsuki Chishouni(9/8/9/9)
-Virtua Fighter 4 EVOLUTION(9/9/9/10)
-Virtual-On MARZ(9/8/8/8)
-J-LEAGUE Pro Soccer Club wo Tsukurou!3(9/8/9/9)
-Initial D Special Stage(7/9/8/9)
-Kunoichi(9/8/8/8)
-Dabitsuku 3 Derby Stallion wo Tsukurou!(8/8/8/8)
-J-LEAGUE Pro Soccer Club wo Tsukurou! '04(8/8/8/8)
-SEGA SUPERSTARS(9/9/7/7)
-Dabitsuku 4 Derby Stallion wo Tsukurou!(9/8/8/7)
-Shining Force NEO(8/8/8/9)
-Sakura Taisen 5(10/8/10/9)
-Pro Yakyuu Team wo Tsukuruou! 3(9/9/8/9)
-Ryu Ga Gotoku(10/10/9/8)
-Sonic Riders(7/9/8/8)
-Kamaitachi no Yoru X3(9/8/8/8)
-PHANTASY STAR UNIVERSE(9/9/8/9)
-Ryu Ga Gotoku 2(9/10/9/10)
-Shining Force EXA(9/9/8/9)
That's all folks!
-
Thanks for confirming Famitsu scores should be removed from the topic. They are below Gamefaqs' 12 year old reviewers' quality.
-
BONUS FEATURE: All time Famitsu's Highest Scores for Sega titles.
Games reviewed on SEGA console are "not understood" or simply famitsu was still a magazine rivalry.
-
Infinite Space, 7/10 - Eurogamer (http://http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/infinite-space-review)
-
Sakura Wars 5 was given a 9.0 by IGN.
-
New Hyper Mag just came in:
Yakuza 3: 8/10
Interesting to note that Yakuza 3 scored higher than Final Fantasy XIII (7/10)
Phantasy Star Zero got a 5/10 but from what I skimmed it sounded like he never played Phantasy star since part IV and was upset it wasn't the same.
Sonic and Sega All Stars Racing got a 6/10
-
Updating frist post with info, thanks ladies! Keep up the good work!
-
Sakura Wars: So Long, My Love
IGN 9
Nintendo Magazine UK 8.1
Nintendo Power 7.5
RPGamer 7
Edge 7
Since SEGA technically developed the title, I think the game counts.
-
^done.
-
The 10/10 for Bayonetta from Hyper is missing in the OP, just thought I would point that out.
-
The 10/10 for Bayonetta from Hyper is missing in the OP, just thought I would point that out.
You know all admins have the power to edit the OP right? LAZY!
-
Sakura Wars: So Long, My Love, 7/10 - Eurogamer (http://http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/sakura-wars-so-long-my-love-review)
-
After Burner Climax, 7/10 - Eurogamer (http://http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/after-burner-climax-review)
7 7 7 7
-
Good game sir, updated!
-
Yakuza 4, 8/10 - Eurogamer (http://http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/yakuza-4-review)
-
Good Alpha Protocol reviews:
1up B+
http://www.1up.com/do/reviewPage?cId=3179545 (http://www.1up.com/do/reviewPage?cId=3179545)
Eurogamer 7/10
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/alpha ... iew?page=3 (http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/alpha-protocol-review?page=3)
Gladriel 7.5/10
http://www.gladriel.com/reviewFull/cont ... ol-review/ (http://www.gladriel.com/reviewFull/content/1581/Alpha-Protocol-review/)
CVG 8.4/10
http://www.computerandvideogames.com/ar ... ?id=248379 (http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=248379)
-
Valkyria Chronicles II
IGN 9.0
http://psp.ign.com/articles/111/1116868p1.html (http://psp.ign.com/articles/111/1116868p1.html)
-
Much love from CRazytails towards SEGA. That is some awesome shiz right there.
SEGA, thank you for becoming awesome once again. I don't know about you guys, but I have been noticing SEGA is coming back more and more as years pass. The fanboy in me wants to cry...
Edit: *Reads own post
I guess that was a bit gay :p. Still, a well deserved score for a great game. I'll be ordering this as soon as I get the paper
-
Hey, Crazy tails! Glad you are happy and I agree Sega are getting much better and I think their worst days have passed. 2008, 2009 and 2010 Sega have gotten better each year.
I must say this though, please try to use the word 'Gay' as a negitive term less often as we have some gay forum members that might take offense. =)
-
Valkyria Chronicles II
Game Informer 8.5/10
EDGE 6/10
-
Wut... anyone know what EDGE gave VC1?
-
Seven. Oddly enough it's the lowest score on Metacritic.
http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstat ... ic-reviews (http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/valkyria-chronicles/critic-reviews)
Edit: Valkyria II got an 8 from Eurogamer
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2010- ... -ii-review (http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2010-08-31-valkyria-chronicles-ii-review)
-
Wut... anyone know what EDGE gave VC1?
Also, what EDGE happened to say about Valkyria Chronicles 2.
With Peace Walker having so recently demonstrated what can be done when a complex, home console series is carefully adapted to PSP, Valkyria Chronicles feels like a missed oppertunity. It's battle system still provides an excellent alternative to the rigid chess boards of many a strategy RPG, but one that feels comprimised rather than optimised for it's new setting. There's nothing wrong with heading back to school, but Valkyria Chronicles was already qualified.
-
I'm waiting for a gametrailers review, For me both IGN and Gametrailers are the most reliable sources and Ithink both have biggest influences in sales.
Who cares about edge anyway lol.
-
Valkyria Chronicles II
Destructoid: 9.5/10
Joystiq: 4/5
-
Gametrailers: 8.4/10 (http://http://www.gametrailers.com/video/review-valkyria-chronicles/703837)
Now that's what i'm talking about
-
Sonic Adventure XBLA 7/10
http://ps3.gamezone.com/reviews/item/so ... n_network/ (http://ps3.gamezone.com/reviews/item/sonic_adventure_review_xbox_live_playstation_network/)
Great compared to the only other two reviews out there. 8-)
-
Sonic 4 - Nintendo Power - Recommended (it is my understanding that this is the highest rating that is given)
-
* Vanquish: 9, 9, 9, 8
Famitsu.
-
^ That's not Famitsu's score.
Its from Famitsu 360, a monthly magazine that is different from the Main Weekly Famitsu.
-
Jeez, considering that the iPhone is pretty much a handheld console, it wouldn't kill websites like MetaCritic, GameStats and GameRankings to aggregate the Sonic 4 iPhone reviews.
Here's some of them:
AppSpy - 4/5 (http://http://www.appspy.com/sonic-hedgehog-4-episode-i-review)
AppTilt - 9/10 (http://http://apptilt.com/review-sonic-the-hedgehog-4-episode-1)
-
I haven't seen any phantasy star portable 2 reviews yet in this thread, so I decided to place some of the good ones.
IGN 8.0 (http://http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4NTo1J1DLsg)
Total Playstation 8.0 (http://http://totalplaystation.com/psp/phantasy-star-portable-2/reviews/9246/)
Meristation 7.5 (http://http://www.meristation.com/v3/des_analisis.php?pic=PSP&idj=cw4c1759bdb7729&id=cw4c927335abae2)
-
Sonic 4, PSN version:
GamesRadar - 9/10 (http://http://www.gamesradar.com/ps3/sonic-the-hedgehog-4-episode-i/review/sonic-the-hedgehog-4-episode-1-review/a-20101008112650143032/g-20090909115153197035)
Ooooooooooh yeeeeah!
-
Sonic 4, Eurogamer, 9/10.
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2010- ... iew?page=2 (http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2010-10-12-sonic-the-hedgehog-4-episode-i-review?page=2)
*spills drink after seeing who reviewed it*
-
Updated the Sonic 4 reviews! gamereactor gave it a 6/10, which is not a good review, however the editor seemed peeved at his staff writer and gave a second opinion review, which was an 8/10
-
VANQUISH, Dengeki PS:85/85/90/85
Obviously PS3 version.
-
Added yet another good Sonic 4 review (9/10 from totalvideogames.com)
-
Updated the Sonic reviews! ONM gives it an 88%: http://www.officialnintendomagazine.co. ... p?id=20481 (http://www.officialnintendomagazine.co.uk/article.php?id=20481)
-
ArsTechnica: Buy it (http://http://arstechnica.com/gaming/reviews/2010/10/sonic-4-episode-one-review-welcome-back-sonic.ars?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=rss)
-
The UK Magazine NGamer have given Sonic Colours a score of 86%!
-
IGN have given Vanquish an 85.
-
Game Informer have given SONIC 4 ep.1 a score of 8,0
-
Gamespot gave vanquish a 9/10
http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/vanquish/review.html (http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/vanquish/review.html)
GOTY 2010 ?
-
Gamespot gave vanquish a 9/10
http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/vanquish/review.html (http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/vanquish/review.html)
GOTY 2010 ?
In a year that had Bayonetta, Red Dead Redemption, Halo Reach, Super Mario Galaxy 2, Yakuza 3, Mass Effect 2 and many more bigger games? Not even close.
As good as Vanquish maybe.
-
Gamespot gave vanquish a 9/10
http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/vanquish/review.html (http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/vanquish/review.html)
GOTY 2010 ?
In a year that had Bayonetta, Red Dead Redemption, Halo Reach, Super Mario Galaxy 2, Yakuza 3, Mass Effect 2 and many more bigger games? Not even close.
As good as Vanquish maybe.
VANQUISH HATER!
Everyone stone him!
-
Gamespot gave vanquish a 9/10
http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/vanquish/review.html (http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/vanquish/review.html)
GOTY 2010 ?
In a year that had Bayonetta, Red Dead Redemption, Halo Reach, Super Mario Galaxy 2, Yakuza 3, Mass Effect 2 and many more bigger games? Not even close.
As good as Vanquish maybe.
VANQUISH HATER!
Everyone stone him!
BAYONETTA, RED DEAD REDEMPTION, HALO REACH, SUPER MARIO GALAXY 2, YAKUZA 3, MASS EFFECT 2 AND MANY MORE BIGGER GAMES HATER!
-
Nintendo Power (USA) gave SONIC COLORS: Wii 9,0 ; NDS 7,5
-
Sonic Free Riders
IGN: 7.5/10 (http://http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NN1XU0ST5J0)
A little shallow, navigating with menus is terrible unless you use voice, but the rest is top notch. Not bad for a Sonic spinoff series that had two previous underachieving titles.
-
added the 7.5!
it's interesting that they called the game "shallow" and yet they said the controls weren't "casual friendly". Perhaps what they meant was that the gameplay was simplistic, but the controls are complicated? I'd prefer that to both complicated gameplay AND controls.
-
I think by shaloow IGN mean light on features or content.
I imagine it doesn't have a great deal to offer value for money.
-
-Seporated Sonic Colours Wii and DS into different catigories as they are quite different games.
-Added IGN review score to Sonic Colours (both)
-Added IGN review for Football Manager
-Added Chu Chu Rocket for iPad/iPhone to the list, added IGN review.
If anyone finds review scores for Sonic Colours, Chu Chu Rocket or Football Manager, post it up.
-
Three review scores for three SONIC games, by Famitsu:
SONIC COLORS(also in Japan it's so named) Wii, 8 / 8 / 8 / 10 - (34/40)
SONIC COLORS NDS, 8 / 8 / 8 / 8 - (32/40)
SONIC FREE RIDERS, 8 / 8 / 8 / 8 - (32/40).
-
Is not very high as a score, but I post it evenly:
Virtual-On Force (Xbox 360): 7 / 7 / 8 / 7 - (29/40), by Famitsu.
-
Impressive scores for Sonic, and I'm glad to see Free Riders get a positive score. It deserves it.
-
Is not very high as a score, but I post it evenly:
Virtual-On Force (Xbox 360): 7 / 7 / 8 / 7 - (29/40), by Famitsu.
For a port of a game that barely has any new content and is almost ten years old now, I think that is pretty damn good!
-
Hey, I noticed Alpha Protocol is not on this list. It did not get consistently great reviews, but many are certainly more credible than the ones picked for this list on Sonic the Hedgehog 4.
http://apps.metacritic.com/games/platfo ... haprotocol (http://apps.metacritic.com/games/platforms/xbox360/alphaprotocol)
http://apps.metacritic.com/games/platfo ... haprotocol (http://apps.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/alphaprotocol)
http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/alpha ... ic-reviews (http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/alpha-protocol/critic-reviews)
-
good not bad