Finally got around to seeing this! Ok, so it released on Friday... but I didn't see it til Sunday. And even two days felt like a long wait. Overall, I really enjoyed it!
The Hits:
• The intro ties in very nicely with LOTR, I could see both trilogies connecting seamlessly
• Martin Freeman as Bilbo - I've always loved Martin in any role he has played: Tim Canterbury in The Office, Arthur Dent in Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, Watson in Sherlock. Now he plays another literary character and does such an awesome job! His face is just so damn hilarious. He doesn't need to say a thing and he can get his point across.
• Gandalf the Gray is BACK! I loved Gandalf in LOTR: FOTR, but found Gandalf the White to be so stoic and boring. So to see the pipe smoking, funny Gandalf back in action was the highlight of the film.
• The dwarfs - they don't all stand out, but there are another two movies to go, so I'm sure each dwarf will get their moment in the trilogy. I really liked Dori, he seemed to be a connoisseur of the finer things like tea and wine, which contrasted with his appearance. Balin was cool as well, he and Thorin had the most screen time for sure. I really liked all the dwarf history. It helped in making me care about their plight.
• The scene with Gollum was another highlight of the film. Acting was great on both sides, very tense moments combined with very funny moments.
• Radagast the Brown - he's so friggen kooky! His bird shit head and bunny sled were just so out there, but they worked.
• The music. I have that damn Misty Mountains theme stuck in my head.
• The action scenes were hectic, but a lot of fun.
• Unlike a lot of people... I liked the goblin king! He was an ugly son of a bitch.
The Misses
• On first watch, it takes time to get back into middle earth. Not to say that the beginning dragged, it was just that you had all these new dwarfs but we knew very little about them. It wasn't until the end of the movie that I really liked them, and on rewatch I'm sure the intro would be a lot stronger now that I'm more familiar with them.
• Unlike LOTR, there is no true villian... yet. Once Smaug appears in full, I'm sure things will really (literally) heat up.
• The white council scene is neat fan service, but it wasn't as strong as I wish it would be. All these returning cast members, but no really exciting dialogue. Mainly its "Gandalf is talking shit... oh wait, he's not." I did really like seeing Christoper Lee again, and nice LOTR foreshadowing.
Overall a great start to what I'm sure will be another fantastic trilogy. I can't really rank it with the other LOTR movies until the trilogy completes, but I'd grade it an A/A-