Video Games New York?
Man I'm like a couple hours from New York lol. Crossing the boarder is no problem explain this VG NY thing I might have to leave the country and join you!
VGNY is worth checking out if you're in NYC, though it isn't worth the trip alone. 90% of their stuff is far too pricey (a disc only Dreamcast game that would be $5 on ebay is $15 at VGNY). But when you enter, it's like "OMGWTF look at all the retro SEGA stuff!!!!!!!1111"
Last time I went, I came away with a few cool deals though. Picked up Floigan Bros and Illbleed for $10 each and almost bought a Japanese fishing rod and Bass Fishing mint in box for $25. They also carry indie DC games, which is pretty cool. I might pick up DUX from there next time I'm in the city.
http://videogamesnewyork.com/