Maybe for Lair, but Eye of Judgment was an excellent game, man! It had its issues, namely the fact you could print the cards yourself and that Sony stopped support too early, but it was a really solid game. Lair ... Lair just kind of sucked.
Here's my experience with Eye of Judgement. I put the disc in, and there was like 4 hours of online updates. After the 4 hours were done, I thought, okay, now I'll do the tutorial and learn how this game works. The tutorial was a half-hour non-interactive video with stupid teenagers, and since I couldn't learn by doing, I got bored and didn't actually learn how to play the game. I tried to play it once and it was frustrating and annoying. I packed it all up and traded it in to Game Stop.