The next Sonic game should have every Sonic character playable, but it should be your choice if you play as them or not. If you do not like Shadow, OH WELL. Stop complaining, just play as Sonic and no one else, do not think about how adding all of those characters could have worsened the budget of the level design and art direction. I am pro choice, after all.
Seriously though, a lot of people buy these kind of games because of the character designers, for sure, but at the end of the day it is going to be the setting and gameplay that keep people interested, not making their characters.
APB had literally the best character customization I have ever seen in my life, but remember what happened to that? I do not even think the game lasted a month.
[youtube:2tckp2yx]1WhOTrc5554[/youtube:2tckp2yx]