Most believe that is the return of Doctor Starline. And granted, a body was never recovered and his methods are similar to him.
But I think it's too obvious, y'know? A red herring. But it does line up well with Starline that I can't help but agree. Even Sonic momentarily saw his face and recognised him.
But, if i had to guess who it could be other than Doctor Starline, I would say it's Claire Voyance.
Ian Flynn was inspired by FOXHOUND from Metal Gear when he came up with the OG Diamond Cutters, and each member, even Whisper, have a FOXHOUND counterpart.
Claire's counterpart is Psycho Mantis. Mantis has the power of causing controlled hallucinations in others, just as the Benefactor can do so via green smoke. While Claire doesn't show she has powers like Psycho Mantis to begin with, it could be she further developed her powers after her supposed "death".
While I like Starline more than any other enemy characters, Claire Voyance would make an interesting comeback than Starline.
But then again, Sonic Rumble Party just teased a new character with this tag :
"Not equal.
No.
A superior replacement."
And this pic :

It's most likely Starline and I don't think it's coincidence with the comic running to #100.
So my bet is on Dr. Starline.