I am kind of surprised George is reacting so poorly to the game. I did not really think it looked that much like Gears outside of some of the characters.
It is not all about the score attacking though, I like how you can just play it like a normal game a lot, kind of has a classic Sonic mentality, where you could speedrun and bounce on all of the badniks, but it was possible to just go through the levels slowly and explore too if you want.
On the Bulletstorm at Vanquish comments, I meant that the style is sort of what Vanquish tried but did not do entirely right, like appealing to more audiences, which I think this will. The story, characters, music, even the menu design is pretty damn similar to Vanquish I think, and Epic Games' people have said they really loved Bayonetta, so I assume they are aware of Vanquish.
As for the humor, it is kind of growing on me. I love how mindless the enemies are, it is like I am fighting everyone who is over level 60 on Gears of War 2.