Trying to be as manly as I can while typing this, but: omg, I had the best trip to the mall today!
Stopped in to hit GameStop. On the way to GS, I noticed that the empty space once occupied by the used game store Play N Trade (closed 3 months back) was now occupied by a place called Game Trader. Stopped in, great prices and selection! I found SEGA Superstars (PS2, didn't have an Eye Toy but I figured I'd hit ebay when I got home) and shuffled through a stack of Dreamcast games. Every game was $8 each, so I got Qbert and Disney's Magical Racing Tour in a buy one get one free sale. $4 each, nice.
Then I finally got to GameStop and snagged their last copy of You Don't Know Jack on the 360. In the back I found a PS2 Eye Toy for the low price of $3. Nice.
Overall, I spent less than $45, got four games, a (lame) accessory and discovered a new store that carries old SEGA games and systems.